Forum for CA (Chartered Accountants work in all fields of business and finance.)

Chartered Accountants/ CPA's/ Finance Professionals.

4 Comments

Amit Khandelia Said,
February 27th, 2007 @2:27 pm  

Madhur,

Just hold on………..If PC continues to be our FM, one day he will publish neagtive list for service Tax.

Boss (Fin Min), you are just too great……. I wish You continue to be the Fin Min of India for infinite period.Your magic wand in the form of (MAT, FBT, BCTT,VAT,Education Cess,STT,EET Regime inspite of EEET, GST Act – all these taxes are introduced by him) is definitely gonna boost our economy…….

mygif
Maninder Sethi Said,
February 27th, 2007 @9:33 pm  

Every day life is getting tougher and tougher. All they claim GOOD BUDGET but in reality they are squeezing money out of people’s pocket, nothing else.

Why in India you need to pay so much taxes? tell me if a genuine person earns a salary of Rs.22000 per month, how much money he needs to pay as tax?

Why his house rent, day today grocery bills, telephone bills, traveling bills and lot of bills are not allowed. IT officials just add back those as they have a limitation of allowances.

Since you all are CA’s, I put this question to mass. Why we cant show our genuine expenditures.

Thanks!
Maninder Sethi!

mygif
Maninder Sethi Said,
March 6th, 2007 @5:37 pm  

no CA has replied yet! I know this question is unanswerable. Even your finance minister didn’t have the answer to this question my dear dudes..

mygif
Madhur Said,
March 7th, 2007 @10:39 am  

Well….Maninder, let me reply to u. It seems you realy want one.

In Income frm Business and Profession, the expenses that are allowed are legitimate business expenditure. The House rent of the owner, his grocery bills, personal telephone bills and personal travellin bills are not allowed.

Similarly, incase of salary, the above expenses are construed as personal expenses and hence not allowed. The entire income from salaries aftr allowing some deduction or benefits(like standard deduction earlier, deduction for HRA, LTC allowance, PF benefits) has to be charged to tax. The allowances for HRA, LTC, LTA, Leave encashment, gratuity, provident fund etc can be viewed as benefits a salaried employee gets. Ofcourse you may argue that the deduction that realy benefited the salaried employees i.e the standard deduction has been withdrawn and has made a hole in our pockets. But noway the expenses that you have mentioned should be allowed or should have been allowed.

I hope this shall put your query to rest.!

mygif

Random Post

Leave Your Comments Below

Please Note: All comments will be hand modified by our authors so any unsuitable comments will be removed and you comments will be appreared after approved