Forum for CA (Chartered Accountants work in all fields of business and finance.)

Chartered Accountants/ CPA's/ Finance Professionals.

4 Comments

CA.Kallol Kolay Said,
March 27th, 2007 @3:50 pm  

Ruthless killing of innocent farmers,incuding ladies and children by police and police-uniformed CPM goons do ensure any industrial growth in West Bengal?!Still scores of bodies are missing!Do focefull acquisition of land,the livelyhood of poor farmers transform a state from farm base to industry?What is the nature of chemical hub?Which chemicals will be produced?Whether the chemicals already discarded by developed countries for the sake of pollution are to be produced here??We have already such one in Haldia,adjacent to Nandigram,The Mitsubishi Chemicals,first discarded by South Afica!……For the sake of humanity denounce state brutality and for the sake of our next generation keep a pollution free India as far as possible. Thanks.

mygif
Amit Khandelia Said,
March 29th, 2007 @9:39 am  

At last, Mr. Buddhadeb Bhattacharya, the CM of West Bengal officially announced yesterday to call off all the plans of setting up chemical hub at Nandigram.

Bad politics by the opposition party is disrupting the growth of the country. At times I feel that too much of democracy is bad for the country. We need to have a trade off between the Capitalist and Democratic system. This is somehting we need to learn from China, our neighbouring country. The way China is handling these issues is incredible.

mygif
Amit Khandelia Said,
March 29th, 2007 @10:46 am  

Indistrialisation is not about brutal killing. It is the diplomat political parties who are pasing a wrong message and spreading violence in the state and not the industry. I don’t think TATA’s or any other Industrialist who are pioneers of globalisation and carry the economy on their shulder will do anything which is against the poor farmers.

The poor farmers who are illiterate don’t appreciate the fact that new industry in the state will provide employment and better infrastructure. The political parties are just teaching them only one slogan ” Go back ! Industry”………..

mygif
CA.Kallol Kolay Said,
March 31st, 2007 @3:35 pm  

I personally feel the author has lack of information in respect of industrilisation.I am putting few questions and observations:

1.Inspite of rapid growth and industrilisation, growth
of work-force decelerate,probabaly 1.24% during 1995-96 to 2004-05,verify NSS report.

2.If globalisation and liberisation are the call of the day,why Saint Mr.Ratan TATA is not directly dealing with the farmers in Singur?Remember RIL did it in Maharastra and Gujrat.More recently DLF directly dealt with peasents at Dankuni in West Bengal ,offered a hefty sum of Rs 35 to 40 Lakh per acre.Whereas WB Govt.is offering a price Rs.8 to 14 lakh per acre in Singur and Dankuni is not far off from Singur.Why??

3.UNO is organising a project to conserve the fertile land bank of the universe,SINGUR is one of the best fertile land bank in India.87%of land acquired for TATA Small Car project is yielding 5 to 6 crops per year.Imagine the fertility!!

4.How many people would be directly employed in TATA project?10,000 people are depending on this land.

5.Enslaving own people for the cause of indutrialisation will no good for ordinary Indians.And just copying the words of few IMF and World Bank deputed economists will great harm to the Indian economy and environment as well.

mygif

Random Post

Leave Your Comments Below

Please Note: All comments will be hand modified by our authors so any unsuitable comments will be removed and you comments will be appreared after approved